Canada Expands Misleading Advertising Rules and Creates New Private Litigation for Misleading Advertising
The Government of Canada has proposed legislation to amend the Competition Act (the “Act”) to, among other things, (i) expand the scope of what constitutes misleading advertising, and (ii) permit private parties to commence civil litigation against alleged misleading advertising (and seek different types of monetary awards in some circumstances). These changes create new compliance obligations and strategic considerations for advertisers in Canada.
Here are four things to know about this new legislation and misleading advertising in Canada:
New Type of Misleading Advertising – Environmental Claims
At present, the Act’s civil provisions provide that advertising can be “misleading” if it is “misleading in a material respect” or if it makes claims related to the “performance, efficacy or length of life of a product that is not based on an adequate and proper test thereof, the proof of which lies on the” advertiser. It can be difficult to establish that environmental claims in advertising are material to a purchaser’s decision to select a product (especially if the claims concern, for example, the effect of the product’s manufacture on the environment). It can also be difficult to establish that environmental claims in advertising relate to the performance of a product (e.g., the claim related to the product’s manufacture does not concern any aspect of the product’s performance). This has limited the applicability of the misleading advertising provisions to so-called “greenwashing claims”. Under the new legislation, misleading advertising will be expanded to include claims concerning “a product’s benefits for protecting the environment” or a product’s benefits for “mitigating the environmental and ecological effects of climate change,” if those claims are not based on adequate prior testing.
Key Takeaways
- Advertising that contains environmental claims, including so-called “greenwashing claims” that convey an impression about the positive environmental benefit of a product or service, can contravene the Act even if they do not materially influence a purchasing decision or concern the performance of a product.
- Advertisers will need to assess carefully if they have “adequate and proper” testing in hand before making environmental claims.
New Private Litigation for Misleading Advertising, Including Monetary Penalties and Awards
At present, only the Commissioner of Competition has standing to challenge advertising as misleading and contrary to the civil provisions of the Act. Under the new legislation, private parties can seek leave from the Competition Tribunal to bring proceedings alleging that advertising is misleading and contrary to the Act. However, the Tribunal will only grant such leave if the Tribunal “is satisfied that it is in the public interest to do so.”
Private parties that obtain leave can use the existing legislation to request that the Tribunal order that an advertiser pay an administrative monetary penalty (which is due to the government). In addition, and only if private parties successfully prove that advertising is misleading in a material respect, private parties can use the existing legislation to request that the Tribunal issue an order that the advertiser “pay an amount, not exceeding the total of the amounts paid to the [advertiser] for the products in respect of which the conduct was engaged in, to be distributed among the persons to whom the products were sold… in any manner that the court considers appropriate.”
Key Takeaways
- Private parties can challenge all types of misleading advertising, if the Tribunal accepts that such a challenge is in the public interest.
- The ability to obtain a financial award that is to be distributed to third parties, including persons other than the plaintiffs (such as all consumers that purchased a product), may create incentives for the class-action plaintiff’s bar to attempt to launch misleading advertising litigation.
New Enforcement Abilities for Breach of Consent Agreements
At present, many misleading advertising investigations by the Commissioner are resolved via a consent agreement with an advertiser. However, it is challenging for the Commissioner to take action against alleged breaches of those consent agreements. The new legislation makes enforcement by the Commissioner significantly simpler. The new legislation permits the Commissioner to apply to a court or the Tribunal for civil enforcement of the consent agreement, including an order to prohibit advertisers from engaging in conduct that breaches the consent agreement and an “administrative monetary penalty in an amount not exceeding $10,000 for each day in which they fail to comply with the agreement…”
Key Takeaway
- It will be significantly easier for the Commissioner to take enforcement action against advertisers that breach consent agreements.
New Processes for Settling Private Misleading Advertising Litigation
Under the new legislation, all settlements of private misleading advertising litigation must be served on the Commissioner. The new legislation creates a process for the Commissioner to apply to the Tribunal to vary or rescind the settlement agreement if the agreement “is not in conformity with the purposes of” the misleading advertising sections of the Act. The language in this new legislation is vague, and so the Commissioner’s actual scope to challenge a settlement agreement is unclear. Separately, settling parties are permitted to have their settlement agreement registered with the Tribunal, which will result in it becoming publicly accessible. The new legislation gives the Commissioner the right to enforce a privately negotiated consent agreement as if it were the Commissioner that had entered into that consent agreement.
Key Takeaway
- Given the multitude of processes that apply to the settlement of private misleading advertising litigation, achieving acceptable terms of settlement may be made more complex.
Looking Forward
The proposed legislation is contained in the Government’s budget and is expected to become law late this year or early next year. While the new expanded definition of misleading advertising and the Commissioner’s ability to enforce breaches of consent agreements will come into force immediately, the new processes for private litigation will not come into effect until one year after the legislation becomes law.
For further information concerning this draft legislation, please contact any member of our Competition and Foreign Investment Group.
Expertise
Authors
Insights
-
Competition and Foreign Investment
The Cineplex Decision – A New Chapter Opens in Canadian Competition Law
The Competition Tribunal released its reasons in Commissioner v. Cineplex on October 3, 2024. It is the first decision under the Competition Act’s “drip pricing” misleading advertising provision… -
Competition and Foreign Investment
Canadian Government’s Approval of Glencore/Teck and a Ministerial Statement Signals Muscular New Standards for Investment Canada Act Undertakings and Metals and Minerals Transactions
Executive SummaryA recent approval under the Investment Canada Act (“ICA”), and a policy statement by the Minister, signals important developments for investors into Canada, including:The… -
Capital Markets
Public Safety Canada Releases Updated Guidance on Modern Slavery Reporting Obligations
The Fighting Against Forced Labour and Child Labour in Supply Chains Act (the “Act”) came into force on January 1, 2024, implementing enhanced reporting requirements for certain entities to… -
Competition and Foreign Investment
The Public Competition Enforcement Review 16th Edition - Canada Chapter
Michael Koch, David Rosner, Josh Zelikovitz and Jon Wall co-authored the Canada Chapter of The Public Competition Enforcement Review 16th Edition.The Public Competition… -
Competition and Foreign Investment
International Comparative Legal Guide - Enforcement of Foreign Judgments 2024, Canada Chapter
Peter Kolla, Julie Rosenthal and Sarah Stothart co-authored the Canada Chapter of International Comparative Legal Guide - Enforcement of Foreign Judgments 2024. The Canada chapter covers common… -
Competition and Foreign Investment
Canada Expands Misleading Advertising Rules and Creates New Private Litigation for Misleading Advertising
The Government of Canada has proposed legislation to amend the Competition Act (the “Act”) to, among other things, (i) expand the scope of what constitutes misleading advertising, and (ii) permit…
Featured Work
-
Mining
Newmont Corporation to sell Musselwhite Gold Mine to Orla Mining for $850 million
Goodmans LLP is advising Newmont Corporation in its agreement to sell the Musselwhite Gold Mine to Orla Mining for $850 million… -
Mining
Newmont Corporation to sell its Éléonore operation to Dhilmar Ltd for $795 million
Goodmans LLP is advising Newmont Corporation in its agreement to sell its Éléonore operation to Dhilmar Ltd for $795 million in cash consideration… -
Mining
Coeur Mining, Inc. to acquire SilverCrest Metals Inc. at an implied equity value of approximately US$1.7 billion
Goodmans LLP acted as Canadian counsel to Coeur Mining, Inc. in connection with entering into a definitive agreement with SilverCrest Metals Inc., whereby pursuant to a plan of arrangement Coeur will… -
Competition and Foreign Investment
TRADER Corporation to be acquired by AutoScout24
Goodmans LLP is acting as Canadian regulatory counsel for TRADER Corporation in connection with its proposed acquisition by AutoScout24 from Thoma Bravo… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Apotex Inc. acquires Searchlight Pharma Inc.
Goodmans LLP advised Apotex Inc. in connection with its acquisition of Searchlight Pharma Inc… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Chord Energy and Enerplus combine in $11 billion transaction
Goodmans LLP acted as Canadian counsel for Chord Energy Corporation in connection with its acquisition of Enerplus Corporation for US$3.7 billion in stock and cash, creating a leading producer in the…
News & Events
-
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans Once Again Receives Top-Tier Recognition from The Legal 500 Canada
We are pleased to announce Goodmans LLP has once again received top-tier recognition from The Legal 500 Canada in their 2025 Guide released today.Recognition from The Legal 500 is based on independent… -
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans Recognized in the Inaugural Edition of Best Law Firms - Canada 2025
Goodmans is delighted to share we are featured in the inaugural edition of Best Law Firms - Canada 2025, recognizing us as one of the country’s exceptional law firms across 40 industries and practices… -
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans Continues to be named one of Canada’s Best Law Firms for 2025
We are pleased to announce Goodmans continues to be featured on The Globe and Mail’s Canada’s Best Law Firms list, recognizing us as one of the country’s best law firms for 2025.Goodmans was listed…