In Darmar Farms Inc. v. Syngenta Canada Inc., the Ontario Court of Appeal allowed a claim of “negligent commercialization” to proceed where the introduction of a new product into the market provoked trade disruptions which resulted in economic loss to market participants who had not actually purchased the product.
The defendant had put its genetically modified corn seed on the market before receiving regulatory approval from Chinese authorities, which then banned all North American corn because it had intermingled with the defendant’s corn seed. The resulting glut in the North American market caused prices to fall. The plaintiff corn grower, who had not purchased the defendant’s product but suffered economic loss as a result of the drop in prices, sued on behalf of itself and “others similarly situated in Canada” in a proposed class action.
Applying the test recently set out by the Supreme Court of Canada in Deloitte & Touche v. Livent Inc. (Receiver of) to determine whether a duty of care could arise under the circumstances, the Court of Appeal found that sufficient facts had been pleaded so that the plaintiff had a reasonable prospect of establishing the relationship of proximity and foreseeability of harm necessary to support a finding that the defendant owed the plaintiff a duty to take care with respect to the timing, manner and scope of the commercialization of its genetically modified corn seed.
The allegations supporting a relationship of proximity were twofold:
- The defendant belonged to industry associations formed for the purpose of protecting the public and participants in the corn market, which associations had warned the defendant of possible trade disruptions if its product were commercialized without appropriate steps being taken to obtain global approvals. In response to these concerns, the defendant had undertaken not to cause harm by commercializing its product without the required global approvals, and the plaintiff had relied on that undertaking.
- The defendant’s genetically modified corn seed would inevitably commingle with all growers’ corn, including the plaintiff’s, so as to impart traits that would affect the growers’ access to certain markets, and the defendant knew this. That was arguably sufficient to create a relationship between them even though the plaintiff did not purchase the defendant’s product.
In the Court’s view, the proximity inquiry largely answered any indeterminacy concerns, and in any event courts should be reluctant to find at the pleadings stage that such concerns negate a duty of care.
The Court of Appeal relied on the 2007 case of Sauer v. Canada (Attorney General), in which an Ontario cattle farmer brought a proposed class action against the manufacturer of cattle feed alleged to have infected a cow in Alberta with “mad cow disease”. The infection of the single cow was sufficient to provoke an international ban on exports of Canadian cattle and beef products, and the plaintiff claimed to have suffered economic loss as a result of the ban even though none of his cattle were affected. In Sauer, allegations as to the integrated nature of the industry and the foreseeable industry-wide consequences of contamination were found to be sufficient indicia of proximity to move the claim for economic loss past the pleadings stage. There was no mention of any undertaking on the defendant’s part or reliance on the plaintiff’s.
The Supreme Court of Canada stressed in Deloitte that an undertaking by the defendant and reliance on that undertaking by the plaintiff are necessary elements of a claim in negligent misrepresentation or negligent performance of services; but it is not clear whether the same is true of claims for pure economic loss which do not fit into those categories.
This is an important point, which will have a considerable impact on the scope of liability. It was not necessary for the Court of Appeal to resolve the question at this stage of the action, but it will likely arise again at the certification stage, where a requirement to prove reliance could raise individual issues that make the claim unsuitable as a class action.
Authors
Insights
-
Capital Markets
Public Safety Canada Releases Updated Guidance on Modern Slavery Reporting Obligations
The Fighting Against Forced Labour and Child Labour in Supply Chains Act (the “Act”) came into force on January 1, 2024, implementing enhanced reporting requirements for certain entities to… -
Crisis Management and Urgent Proceedings
Panoramic Next: Crisis Management 2024 - Canada Chapter
Mark Dunn and Sarah Stothart co-authored the Canada Chapter of Panoramic Next: Crisis Management 2024. Through a series of interviews with expert legal… -
Capital Markets
Modern Slavery Reporting Obligations for Canadian Entities Effective January 1, 2024
The Fighting Against Forced Labour and Child Labour in Supply Chains Act (the “Act”) came into force on January 1, 2024, implementing enhanced reporting requirements for certain companies and… -
Dispute Resolution
Director Duties and Climate Change
Decisions earlier this year from the English courts in ClientEarth v Shell Plc et al., and the recent appeal decision from the Court of Appeal of England and Wales, shed light on climate change issues… -
Intellectual Property
Canadian Intellectual Property Office Increases Fees Effective January 1, 2024
As of January 1, 2024, the Canadian Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) will be increasing most of its fees by 25%. Filing fees, renewal fees, opposition filing fees, as well as fees for initiating… -
Dispute Resolution
The Courtroom Climate, Best Lawyers
In Best Lawyers’ recent 2023 Business Edition, Peter Kolla explores justiciability, and other limitations Canadian Courts face when trying climate change cases. Excerpt from "The Climate…
Featured Work
-
Capital Markets
Dye & Durham’s defence of requisition from Engine Capital
Goodmans is acting for the board of Dye & Durham in connection with a defence of requisition from Engine Capital. The company announced on March 15, 2024 that it had received a letter… -
Capital Markets
Board of WonderFi Technologies Inc.’s proxy defense from KAOS Capital and Mogo
Goodmans is acting for the special committee of the board of WonderFi Technologies Inc in connection with its defense of a proxy contest launched by KAOS Capital and MOGO. KAOS Capital is a… -
Restructuring
LoyaltyOne cross-border restructuring
Goodmans LLP is counsel to KSV Restructuring Inc. in its capacity as court-appointed monitor of LoyaltyOne, Co. in its restructuring proceedings under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act before… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Browning West issues letter to Gildan Activewear’s board of directors outlining steps to restore stakeholder confidence
Goodmans LLP is acting for Browning West, LP in connection with issuing a letter to Gildan Activewear Inc. advocating for the reinstatement of its former CEO, Glenn Chamandy… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Apotex to acquire Searchlight Pharma
Goodmans LLP is acting for Apotex Inc. in connection with its acquisition of Searchlight Pharma Inc… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Coinsquare, WonderFi and CoinSmart close business combination
Goodmans LLP acted for Coinsquare Ltd. in its business combination transaction with WonderFi Technologies Inc. and CoinSmart Financial Inc…
News & Events
-
Technology
Peter Ruby at OBA's ADR Strategies for Technology Disputes: Crafting Efficient Resolutions
Join Peter Ruby on May 23rd at 12:00 pm for the ADR Strategies for Technology Disputes: Crafting Efficient Resolutions, webinar at The Canadian Bar Association. Elevate your conflict… -
Banking and Financial Services
The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2024 Continues to Recognize Goodmans
We are proud to announce Goodmans LLP has once again been recognized in the 2024 edition of The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory.91 Goodmans lawyers have been recognized as top-tier in their… -
Dispute Resolution
Goodmans Partners Recognized in the Lexpert Special Edition: Litigation 2023
We are delighted to announce the Lexpert Special Edition: Litigation 2023 once again features Goodmans partners among Canada's experts in litigation.Congratulations to our 13 featured…