Ontario Simplifies Regulation of Asset Transfers and Individual Pension Plans
Ontario recently amended the Pension Benefits Act (PBA) as part of a program to reduce regulatory burdens and governmental red tape. The amendments simplify the regulatory approval process for transferring assets from one pension plan to another and exempt individual pension plans and designated plans from PBA regulation.
The amendments were implemented by Ontario's Bill 213, An Act to reduce burdens on people and businesses (“Bill 213”), which received Royal Assent and is in force as of December 8, 2020.
Asset Transfers
The PBA requires the CEO of the Financial Services Regulatory Authority (FSRA) to consent to the transfer of any assets between pension plans, including any transfers on account of a sale of a business, corporate reorganization or merger. The asset transfer rules in the PBA establish strict requirements and timelines. The timelines for notices to members, former members and retirees, and any trade unions representing affected members are strict, with no remedy for delays. Bill 213 now enables the CEO of FSRA to waive or vary the asset transfer notice requirements of the asset transfer rules. FSRA also has the authority to make and waive its own rules concerning such notice requirements that relate to the asset transfer proposal and the related consent application to the CEO of FSRA.
This rule-making authority also applies to applications to convert single employer pension plans to jointly sponsored pension plans. The PBA amendments are consistent with the updated process for these types of conversions announced by FSRA on October 22, 2020. FSRA has also proposed new guidance for the general asset transfer process, which will aim to simplify that process.
The PBA amendments and these steps from FSRA show the Ontario government and its pension regulator are attempting to ease the asset transfer process away from the restrictive rules and towards a streamlined, outcome-focused process. Under the new rules, it is anticipated pension plan administrators will be able to receive consent to transfer assets more expeditiously than before and, at the same time, the greater flexibility provided to the regulator should allow for the continued protection of pension plan member entitlements.
Individual Pension Plans and Designated Plans
Bill 213 also amends the PBA to permit individual pension plans (IPPs) and designated plans to be exempt from application of the PBA, its regulations and FSRA’s regulatory oversight.
IPPs are registered pension plans providing defined benefits that have three or fewer members with a certain relationship to the employer or are certain “designated plans”. Designated plans under the Income Tax Act (ITA) require the participant to have a certain level of pension credits. In practice, the plans are typically used by significant shareholders of closely held corporations.
Before Bill 213, IPPs and designated plans were subject to regulation by the PBA. Now, all IPPs and designated plans established after December 8, 2020 are exempt from PBA application. As well, any IPP or designated plan that was established on or before December 8, 2020, may become exempt from PBA application if the employer files an election and if certain other conditions are satisfied, including obtaining the consent of plan members. The plans would remain subject to the ITA.
These amendments to the PBA are significant because exempted IPPs and designated plans will no longer be required to follow the PBA’s rules for matters such as registration of the plan, filing actuarial valuations, funding the plan or completing annual filing requirements. This should significantly reduce compliance and administration costs for the employer, while the employee will no longer have the protection of the PBA and the enforcement from FSRA. The lack of protection may be less of a concern from a public policy perspective if the plan members are the persons who own and control the employer or are related to them.
The exemption may also make IPPs and designated plans more popular retirement vehicles for employers. The benefits of such plans, like superior tax treatment and contribution room as compared to RRSPs, may have been reduced by the cost and administrative burden. Without those burdens, employers may be more inclined to establish an IPP or designated plans for eligible employees.
Ontario now joins Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba and Quebec in exempting such plans from pension legislation.
Summary
The amendments to the PBA contained in Bill 213 reflect a significant reduction in government regulation and red tape with respect to asset transfers, IPPs and designated plans. The reduction of cost and complexity of asset transfers will be welcome to both buyers and sellers in merger and acquisition transactions. With the exemption of IPPs and designated plans, employers are granted more freedom in establishing such plans.
Authors
Insights
-
Employment, Pensions and Executive Compensation
Panoramic: Pensions & Retirement Plans 2025 – Canada Chapter
Brian Sweigman authored the Canada Chapter of Lexology's Panoramic: Pensions & Retirement Plans 2025. This guide offers a side-by-side comparison of local insights, including into the statutory… -
Employment, Pensions and Executive Compensation
Ontario's Working for Workers Five Act; It May be Time to Review Your Employment Policies
Make it a Priority to Review and Update Your Employment Agreements, Policies and HandbooksEmployment law has been evolving rapidly over the past few years making it critical for employers to review… -
Employment, Pensions and Executive Compensation
Key Court Rulings Shaping the Enforceability of Employment Agreements
Employment law has been evolving rapidly over the past few years making it critical for employers to keep up to date with new case law. We suggest that employers make it a priority to review and… -
Employment, Pensions and Executive Compensation
Consideration of Government of Canada’s proposal to remove 30% rule for pension funds, Lexpert
In a recent article for Lexpert.ca, author Brian Sweigman explores how the context has changed both for Canadian pension funds, as global investment leaders seeking to maximize returns for… -
Employment, Pensions and Executive Compensation
Understanding Cyber Risks for Pension Plan Administrators, ACPM
Brian Sweigman published an article in The Observer, ACPM. Excerpt from "Understanding Cyber Risks for Pension Plan Administrators": As pension plans are increasingly relying on technology… -
Employment, Pensions and Executive Compensation
Pensions & Retirement Plans 2023 - Canada Chapter
Brian Sweigman authored the Canada Chapter of Lexology's Pensions & Retirement Plans 2023 Guide. The Pensions & Retirement Plans Guide offers a side-by-side comparison of local insights…
Featured Work
-
Private Equity and Venture Capital
OMERS sells majority interest in CEDA to Hillcore Group
Goodmans LLP advised OMERS Private Equity Inc., a subsidiary of OMERS, in connection with the sale of its majority interest in CEDA to Hillcore Group… -
Technology
Canapi Ventures leads Series B investment round in FISPAN
Goodmans LLP acted for Centerharbor Canapi Ventures Investment Advisor LLP (“Canapi Ventures”) in connection with its $30 million Series B funding in FISPAN Services Inc., the industry leader in… -
REITS and Income Securities
InterRent REIT to be acquired by consortium that includes CLV Group in partnership with GIC in $4 billion all-cash transaction
Goodmans LLP is acting for a consortium that includes CLV Group Inc. in partnership with GIC in connection with the acquisition of InterRent REIT, whereby pursuant to a plan of arrangement a newly… -
Energy
Carlyle launches new renewables platform with Amp Energy carve-outs
Goodmans LLP acted for Amp Energy in connection with the carve-out of its Australian and UK portfolios of power generation and storage assets by global investment firm, Carlyle… -
Banking and Financial Services
Docebo Inc. enters into new revolving operating credit facility
Goodmans advised Docebo Inc. in connection with a new revolving operating credit facility with National Bank of Canada… -
Communications and Media
PSP Investments and BCE Inc. announce strategic partnership to create Network FiberCo
Goodmans LLP is acting as Canadian counsel to the Public Sector Pension Investment Board (“PSP Investments”) in connection with the formation of Network FiberCo, a long-term strategic partnership with…
News & Events
-
Aging and Health Care
The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2025 Once Again Recognizes Goodmans
We are proud to announce Goodmans LLP continues to be recognized in the 2025 edition of The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory.Congratulations to the 96 Goodmans lawyers recognized as leaders across… -
Employment, Pensions and Executive Compensation
Brian Sweigman at the IFEBP's Certified Employee Benefit Specialist Program
On December 16th, Goodmans partner Brian Sweigman lead the session "Complying with Legislative and Best Practices in Pension Plan Asset Investment" as part of the Certified Employee Benefit Specialist… -
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans Recognized in the Inaugural Edition of Best Law Firms - Canada 2025
Goodmans is delighted to share we are featured in the inaugural edition of Best Law Firms - Canada 2025, recognizing us as one of the country’s exceptional law firms across 40 industries and practices…