April 01, 2017

The compromises of tenure, Canadian Lawyer

Neill May is a contributor to Canadian Lawyer magazine. This article first appeared in the April, 2017 issue.

Excerpt from "The compromises of tenure":

The Allstate Corporation recently received a shareholder proposal requesting that its board adopt a rule that, wherever possible, its lead director have less than 12 years tenure on the board. The stated rationale for the proposal was a concern that a longer tenure compromises director independence.

"Goodmans is great to work with, distilling very complicated issues and matters to their actionable essence." — Chambers Global
Goodmans LLP continues to be a leader in the corporate and M&A space, bringing strength to advising major multinational corporates and financial institutions involved in high-value, multi-jurisdictional M&A, reorganisations and corporate governance matters. — The Legal 500 Canada
Goodmans have excellent subject matter expertise and actionable strategy and advice. They give deep confidence of their ability to capably handle complex and sophisticated matters. — Chambers Canada
The corporate and commercial team has impressive depth with experienced and highly skilled counsel at all relevant levels, from senior partner to junior associate. — Chambers Canada
The Corporate/Commercial team at Goodmans make it seem as though we are their only client. They are our go-to external corporate-commercial counsel. — Chambers Canada
Clients note, "They have a good team of very experienced lawyers who know the process, " adding, "They have a good bench strength." — Chambers Canada
Clients note, "They get our business and what we're trying to accomplish. It's not just technical advice." — Chambers Canada
One interviewee reported, "The Goodmans team as a whole is excellent," adding: "The lawyers are very responsive and get the job done. It is of great assurance to have them as our legal advisers." — Chambers Canada
One client noted, "...they handled a very complicated transaction involving many jurisdictions and did a very good job. They are always able to make comparative decisions through a relatively simple way and try to balance risk and find solutions." — Chambers Canada
Clients note, "The client service at Goodmans has always been excellent, and they are very deep from a corporate and financing perspective." — Chambers Global
Interviewees praise the firm's work on cross-border matters, saying: "The team's coordination is superb, its work ethic unparalleled and the service excellent." — Chambers Global
One client noted, "very strong legal minds, focus in on the business issues...good communicators, include my internal team as much or as little as we may want on a particular project." — IFLR1000
....punches above its weight for big-ticket M&A in Canada, recently advising on substantial transactions in mining, energy, technology and cannabis sectors. — Chambers Global
Clients commend Goodmans for being, "very entrepreneurial in their culture, in addition to being able to provide sophisticated and excellent legal assistance." — Chambers Canada

Insights

Guides

September 24, 2025 Mergers and Acquisitions

A Look Inside Canadian Insider Trading Policies

A Detailed Survey of Canadian Insider Trading Policies was developed by Goodmans LLP to highlight key trends in insider trading policy governance, based on a review of policies from 50 TSX-listed…
Client Updates

September 09, 2025 Capital Markets

Successful Exercise of Dissent Rights Reaffirms Importance of Transaction Price

In a rare example of a successful exercise of statutory dissent rights, a group of shareholders dissenting from a court-approved merger recently obtained a fair value determination five times above…
Client Updates

May 06, 2025 Mining

Ontario Proposes Limits on Critical Mineral and Essential Infrastructure Investments by Non-Canadians

In a political environment charged with concerns about foreign control over critical minerals and essential infrastructure, the Ontario government has introduced new legislation to safeguard those…
Articles

April 22, 2025 Shareholder Activism

Navigating shareholder activism: The role of shareholder-called meetings, Lexpert

In a recent article for Lexpert.ca, authors Jonathan Feldman and Gurratan Gill discuss the legal framework governing shareholder-called meetings in Canada and highlights key considerations for both…
Articles

February 28, 2025 Mergers and Acquisitions

Canada's Updated Merger Control Laws-How the Changes Impact Strategies for Practitioners and Merging Companies, American Bar Association

David Rosner authored Canada's Updated Merger Control Laws-How the Changes Impact Strategies for Practitioners and Merging Companies in American Bar Association's Antitrust Source Magazine. This…
Client Updates

December 11, 2024 Capital Markets

Canada Initiates Consultations and Proposes New Measures to Strengthen Anti-Modern Slavery Efforts

The Fighting Against Forced Labour and Child Labour in Supply Chains Act (the “Act”) came into force on January 1, 2024, implementing enhanced reporting requirements for certain entities to combat…

View All Insights

Practices

Industries

The compromises of tenure, Canadian Lawyer

Neill May

Site Search

The compromises of tenure, Canadian Lawyer

Expertise

Authors

Insights

Featured Work

News & Events