Ontario Court of Appeal Enforces Contractual Waiver of Statutory Dissent Rights
Overview
Ontario’s Court of Appeal concluded in a recent decision that, subject to limited exceptions, shareholders can contractually waive statutory “dissent rights”, which allow shareholders to dissent in respect of certain fundamental corporate actions and receive the fair value of their common shares (as determined by a court) in cash. While contractually waiving dissent rights is a relatively common practice by shareholders of many private corporations, this is the first time that an appellate court in Canada has confirmed the validity of such a waiver. The decision also contains other lessons for drafting waivers of corporate law statutory rights.
Background
The case of Husack v. Husack involved a family dispute regarding the liquidation of the estate of the family patriarch, Frank Husack. The assets of the estate were held through a corporation governed by Ontario’s Business Corporations Act (the “OBCA”). The unanimous shareholders agreement governing the corporation (the “USA”) authorized Mr. Husack’s wife, Evelyn Husack, in her capacity as estate trustee, to sell all or substantially all of the assets of the estate on terms determined in her absolute discretion. It also contained a broad waiver by each shareholder of all statutory rights under the OBCA that may be in conflict with the USA, without referring explicitly to dissent rights or any other specific statutory rights.
In 2019, all of the estate trustees other than one of Mr. Husack’s daughters (the “Applicant”) voted in favour of liquidating the assets of the estate. The Applicant sought to exercise the dissent rights provided in the OBCA that apply when an OBCA corporation sells “all or substantially all” of its assets.
The Decision
The lower Court held, as a general principle, that statutory rights can be waived by contract unless such waiver is unconscionable or there is an overriding public policy reason not to enforce the waiver. Even though the broad waiver in the USA did not explicitly refer to dissent rights, the Court nonetheless found that the unequivocal discretion granted to Ms. Husack in the USA to liquidate the estate in her absolute discretion, combined with the broad general waiver of any statutory rights that might be in conflict with the USA, clearly and unambiguously waived shareholders’ right to dissent in respect of the estate liquidation. The Court found that the contractual provisions in question were not unconscionable, nor was there a public policy reason to prevent their enforcement. The Court of Appeal affirmed the lower Court’s decision.
Key Takeaways
The decision is helpful to contracting parties and practitioners insofar as it confirms that shareholders generally have the ability, subject to limited exceptions, to waive statutory corporate law rights. At the same time, the fact that the Court inferred a waiver of dissent rights from a general clause that did not explicitly refer to those rights warrants caution when drafting these waivers to ensure that they properly reflect the scope intended by the parties. The fact that the Court relied upon another provision of the USA (i.e., the right of Ms. Husack to liquidate the estate in her absolute discretion) in interpreting the breadth of the waiver underscores the importance of considering the provisions of the agreement as a whole when drafting these clauses. In many cases, it may be preferable for the parties to explicitly state what rights are – and are not – being waived. Finally, neither the lower Court nor the Court of Appeal provided any general guidance on the public policy criteria that might justify a decision not to enforce a contractual waiver of statutory corporate law rights, either generally or in any particular circumstances. As a result some enduring ambiguity remains as to when such waivers may not be enforceable.
For further information regarding this update, please contact any member of our Capital Markets Group.
Expertise
Authors
Insights
-
Capital Markets
Canadian Securities Administrators Further Extend Compliance Deadline in Interim Approach to Value-Referenced Crypto Assets
On September 26, 2024, the CSA provided a further update for crypto asset trading platforms (CTPs) that are registered, or that have provided a pre-registration undertaking (PRU), on the interim… -
Capital Markets
Clarification on Rules Relating to the Removal of Directors by Shareholders
In OneMove Capital Corporation v. Dye & Durham Limited (“OneMove v. D&D”), the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (the “Court”) held that shareholders may not submit a proposal under section… -
Structured Finance and Derivatives
Derivatives Business Conduct Rule Coming into Force this Month; CSA Publishes FAQs
The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) recently published CSA Staff Notice 93-302 Frequently Asked Questions About National Instrument 93-101 Derivatives: Business Conduct (FAQs), which… -
Banking and Financial Services
Canadian Securities Regulators Announce Temporary Exemptions For Derivatives Dealers and Advisers
On July 25, 2024, the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) introduced temporary exemptions from certain provisions of National Instrument 93-101 concerning Derivatives: Business Conduct (the… -
Capital Markets
Delaware Court Finds Advance Notice Bylaw Amendments Unenforceable, But Denies Relief Based on Dissident Shareholders’ Deceptive Conduct
The Supreme Court of Delaware’s recent decision in Kellner v. AIM ImmunoTech Inc. provides important guidance on the limits of a board’s authority to amend an “advance notice” bylaw in the context of… -
REITS and Income Securities
The Legal Industry Reviews Edition 5 - REITs Chapter
Stephen Pincus, Brenda Gosselin, and Bill Gorman have co-authored The Canadian REIT Structure in the fifth edition of The Legal Industry Reviews Canada.To view the…
Featured Work
-
Banking and Financial Services
Majority interest in Vault Credit Corporation and Vault Home Credit Corporation sold for $60 Million to HB Leaseco affiliate
Goodmans LLP represented Vault Credit Corporation and Vault Home Credit Corporation in the sale of Chesswood Group Limited's entire interest in Vault to an affiliate of HB Leaseco Holdings Inc., in… -
Capital Markets
Saba Capital reaches agreement with Citadel Income Fund
Goodmans LLP acted for Saba Capital Management, L.P. in relation to its agreement with Citadel Income Fund and its manager, Artemis Investment Management Limited following a protracted dispute… -
Capital Markets
RioCan REIT completes private placement offering of $300 million Series AK debentures
Goodmans LLP advised RioCan Real Estate Investment Trust in connection with a brokered private placement offering of $300 million principal amount of Series AK senior unsecured debentures… -
Mining
Hudbay Minerals completes US$402 million bought deal equity offering
Goodmans LLP advised Hudbay Minerals Inc. in the public offering of its common shares for aggregate gross proceeds of US$402,477,000, including the full exercise of the underwriters’ overallotment… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Screaming Eagle merges with Lionsgate Studios
Goodmans LLP acted for Screaming Eagle Acquisition Corp. in connection with its merger with the Studio Business of Lionsgate Entertainment Corp., comprised of its Television Studio and Motion Picture… -
Capital Markets
Dye & Durham’s defence of requisition from Engine Capital
Goodmans LLP is acting for the board of Dye & Durham in connection with a defence of requisition from Engine Capital…
News & Events
-
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans Continues to be named one of Canada’s Best Law Firms for 2025
We are pleased to announce Goodmans continues to be featured on The Globe and Mail’s Canada’s Best Law Firms list, recognizing us as one of the country’s best law firms for 2025.Goodmans was listed… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Chambers and Partners Once Again Honours Goodmans with Top-Tier Recognition
We are delighted to announce Goodmans LLP continues to receive top-tier recognition from Chambers and Partners in the Chambers Canada 2025 Guide.Recognition from Chambers and Partners is based on… -
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans Lawyers Recognized in the Lexpert Special Edition: Finance and M&A 2024
We are delighted to announce the Lexpert Special Edition: Finance and M&A 2024 once again features Goodmans lawyers among Canada's experts.Congratulations to our 33 featured lawyers:Alan…