U.S. District Court Finds NBA Top Shot Moments may be Subject to U.S. Securities Laws
On May 12, 2021, a class action law suit was filed against Dapper Labs, Inc. in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York (the “Court”) alleging that Dapper Labs violated U.S. securities laws by offering certain non-fungible tokens (“NFTs”) without a registration statement as required by U.S. securities laws. On February 22, 2023, the Court denied Dapper Labs’ request to dismiss the suit before trial and found that the purchasers of its NFTs had sufficiently demonstrated there was a triable issue surrounding whether such NFTs are securities. This decision suggests that, in certain circumstances, NFT and digital asset sales may be considered securities offerings to which U.S. securities laws apply.
NBA Top Shot Moments
Dapper Labs, a Canadian corporation based in Vancouver, British Columbia, develops applications that run on blockchain technology. At a high level, a blockchain is a decentralized and distributed digital ledger where all transactions are validated by a network of users. In September 2019, Dapper Labs created its own blockchain called the Flow Blockchain, which hosts all of its applications and, most importantly, all of Dapper Labs’ transactions are validated on its Flow Blockchain. Such transactions include the sale of Dapper Labs’ most prolific NFTs – NBA Top Shot Moments (“Moments”).
Moments launched in July 2019 as part of a joint venture between Dapper Labs, the National Basketball Association (“NBA”) and the National Basketball Players Association. Moments are tradeable NFTs that allow purchasers to buy, sell and collect officially licensed video highlights of the NBA. Moments are unique digital assets whose authenticity and ownership are recorded on the Flow Blockchain, but ownership is limited to the NFT itself; purchasers of a Moment acquire no rights to the NBA game highlight depicted in the video clip, the underlying artwork or any other intellectual property from the NBA.
Moments can be acquired in two ways. The first option is to purchase Moments directly through Dapper Labs in “packs”, similar to buying a pack of physical sports trading cards. The second option is to purchase Moments through a secondary marketplace, which is hosted and entirely controlled by Dapper Labs. Like any secondary marketplace, owners can sell Moments to other interested purchasers at an agreed price. All sales and transfers are recorded only on the Flow Blockchain.
The Class Action
The class action was filed in May of 2021 by certain purchasers of Moment NFTs (the “Plaintiffs”) against Dapper Labs and its Chief Executive Officer (the “Defendants”). The Plaintiffs alleged that the Defendants breached Sections 5 and 12(a)(1) of the U.S. Securities Act of 1933 (the “Securities Act”) by actively promoting, offering and selling Moments without filing a registration statement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”).
On January 27, 2022, the Defendants filed a pre-motion letter addressed to the Plaintiffs stating the action should be dismissed because “basketball cards are not securities.” The Plaintiffs filed their response on February 3, 2022, and while they did not disagree with the above statement, they insisted that Moments are “not basketball cards.” Instead, the Plaintiffs claimed that Moments are “crypto assets” that can be re-sold on a secondary market that is completely controlled by Dapper Labs and, as such, Moments are securities which should be subject to securities law registration requirements. On August 31, 2022, the Defendants filed a motion to dismiss the class action.
The Court’s Ruling
The Court held that the claims sufficiently alleged that Moments were an offer of an “investment contract” and therefore a security required to be registered with the SEC, and denied the Defendants’ motion to dismiss.
Under the Securities Act, the definition of a security includes an “investment contract”. To determine what constitutes an investment contract, the Court once again relied on the “Howey” test established by the U.S. Supreme Court in SEC v. Howey. The Howey test defines an investment contract as (i) an investment of money, (ii) in a common enterprise, (iii) with profits to be derived solely from the efforts of others.
The Court quickly concluded that the owners of Moments spent a considerable amount of money to purchase the NFTs, satisfying the first prong of the Howey test. Next, the Court found that a common enterprise was established since Dapper Labs pooled funds to raise additional capital to sustain the Flow Blockchain and noted that, should the Flow Blockchain collapse, the value of all Moments would go to zero. This factor satisfied the second prong of the Howey test since the NFT owners’ and Dapper Labs’ fortunes were tied together, and thus an investment in a common enterprise existed. Finally, the Court found that the Defendants made numerous public statements, including through marketing tools such as Twitter, which objectively led purchasers to expect profits. Interestingly, the Court noted that while the word “profit” was not used in its Tweets, Dapper Labs’ use of certain emojis – namely rocket ships, money bags and stock charts – objectively implied a financial return on investment. In addition, because Dapper Labs controlled the entire marketplace for Moments, its continued management and efforts to maintain an ecosystem for trading its NFTs sufficiently satisfied the third prong of the Howey test.
Implications
Dapper Labs publicly offered NFTs recorded on its privately controlled blockchain – a blockchain which dictated the value of such digital assets – and engaged in overt marketing efforts to promote sales while touting the potential to earn substantial returns. The Court’s decision indicates that, at least in similar instances, NFTs and digital asset sales may constitute securities offerings under U.S. securities laws. The Court was clear, however, that not all NFTs offered or sold by a company will be treated as securities, and “each scheme must be assessed on a case by case basis.”
Platforms like Dapper Labs promoting trading in digital assets that bear the hallmarks of a security should understand that, while NFTs and digital assets are unique and still evolving, the courts will continue to apply existing securities laws to businesses based on blockchain technology and will consider the economic realities of a transaction as a whole in determining whether digital assets are securities.
Notably, this decision is only the denial of a motion to dismiss and Dapper Labs was given 21 days to respond to the Court’s order. However, this important decision shines further light on how the courts continue to apply securities laws to businesses based on this evolving technology.
Goodmans Technology Group
Blockchain technology is quickly transforming the corporate landscape, disrupting many industries and creating novel legal challenges like those described above. Goodmans’ technology practice offers unparalleled expert advice to allow our clients to capitalize on the benefits of this exponential technology while remaining abreast of the complex laws and evolving regulations that govern it. Our lawyers deliver innovative and sophisticated solutions to meet the challenges of this new and evolving industry in the areas of corporate and securities laws (including advising on ICOs and other token offerings), venture financing, investment funds, tax law, brokers, consulting firms and exchangers.
As blockchain radically changes business as we know it, Goodmans remains ahead of the pack in this new technology space. For additional information on these issues and opportunities, please contact any member of our Technology Group.
Authors
Insights
-
Tax
CRA Suggests Depositing Cryptocurrency with Trading Platform Could Trigger Tax
On November 2, 2023, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) answered a series of questions as part of the Association de planification fiscal et financière’s annual conference in Quebec City that may have… -
Technology
Canadian Cleantech is Growing
In October 2023, Export Development Canada (EDC) published its annual report on Canadian clean technology (“cleantech”). The report highlights two major industry trends: (1) a dramatic increase in… -
Technology
Proptech Startup Promise Robotics Completes $20.8M Series A Financing
Promise Robotics, a Toronto-based AI company developing a cloud-based industrial production platform for robotic construction and assembly, has raised $20.8 million CAD in Series A financing as it… -
Technology
U of T's Faculty of Pharmacy Launches a new 'self-driving' laboratory
The University of Toronto’s Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy is building a new autonomous lab which uses artificial intelligence (“AI”), automation, and advanced computing for the autonomous discovery… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Investing in the Future: Navigating the Risks and Rewards in AI-Related Transactions
Following the release of ChatGPT in late 2022, the significant developments in artificial intelligence (“AI”) over the last several years – and in generative AI in particular – have caught the… -
Technology
Meta Announces New Generative AI Features for Advertisers
Meta announced last week that it has launched its first generative AI features for advertisers. The new features –Background Generation, Image Expansion, and Text Variations – will allow advertisers…
Featured Work
-
Aging and Health Care
Homecare Hub secures seed funding for its senior care platform
Goodmans LLP acted for Homecare Hub in raising C$3.4 million in an all-equity seed funding round with participation from Inception Health, Ballad Ventures, Blue Lion Global, CABHI, and AARP… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Ratio.City acquired by Esri Canada
Goodmans LLP acted for Ratio.City in its acquisition by Esri Canada… -
Technology
Carbon Upcycling Technologies US$26M Series A Financing Led by BDC and Climate Investment
Goodmans LLP acted for Carbon Upcycling Technologies (CUT) on the closing of their $26m USD Series A financing led by BDC and Climate Investment (CI) to deploy its carbon capture and utilization (CCU… -
Technology
That Clean Life Acquired by Practice Better to Continue Expansion
Goodmans LLP acted for That Clean Life in its sale to Practice Better. Practice Better is a practice-management software platform for health and wellness professionals, while That Clean Life offers… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Docebo Inc. acquires Edugo.AI
Goodmans LLP acted for Docebo Inc. (“Docebo”) in its acquisition of Edugo.AI (“Edugo”), a Generative AI-based Learning Technology that uses advanced Large Language Models and algorithms to optimize… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Sale of CampBrain to Clubessential Subsidiary Vermont Systems
Goodmans LLP acted for CampBrain, a best-in-class SaaS solution for camp management and registration, in connection with its sale to Clubessential subsidiary Vermont Systems, the leading provider of…
News & Events
-
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans Continues to Receive Top Tier Recognition from The Legal 500 Canada
We are pleased to announce Goodmans LLP has once again received top tier recognition from The Legal 500 Canada in their 2024 Guide released today. Recognition from The Legal 500 is based on… -
Banking and Financial Services
Goodmans named one of Canada's Best Law Firms for 2024
We’re pleased to announce Goodmans was once again named to The Globe and Mail’s Canada’s Best Law Firms list, recognizing us as one of the country’s best law firms for 2024.Goodmans was… -
Technology
Colin Romano at Commercial Arrangements in NFTs 2023
Colin Romano presents as faculty at Osgoode’s Certificate in Blockchain Law CPD program on Commercial Arrangements in NFTs on November 8, 2023.This presentation is for professionals participating in…