Goodmans IP Litigation Team Represents NCS on Successful Patent Appeal
Over the past decade, the Goodmans IP Litigation Team has developed a specialized practice in assuming carriage of appeals taken from unsuccessful patent trial-level decisions. These appeals include:
- Evolution Technologies v. Human Care Canada, 2019 FCA 209;
- GEMAK Trust v. Jempak Corporation, 2022 FCA 141;
- Sandoz Canada v. Janssen, 2023 FCA 221; and
- Pharmascience v. Janssen, 2024 FCA 23.
In late 2023, by way of a lengthy trial decision of the Federal Court (2023 FC 1486), NCS Multistage Inc. (“NCS”) was found to infringe a patent related to downhole equipment used in hydraulic fracturing (or fracking).
Shortly thereafter, the Goodmans IP Litigation Team, led by Andrew Brodkin and Jordan Scopa, were retained to take carriage of NCS’s appeal.
After a hearing in early April 2025, this week, the Federal Court of Appeal issued a decision allowing NCS’s appeal, setting aside the relevant paragraphs of the trial judgment and remitting certain issues to be decided by the Federal Court: NCS v. Kobold, 2025 FCA 187.
The Federal Court of Appeal’s decision addresses issues relating to:
- claims construction (including claim scope and dependencies);
- double patenting (including the application of double patenting to divisional applications that expire on the same date as their parent application); and
- costs awards (including procedural fairness and the evidence required to support a claim to costs based on a percentage of actual legal fees).
Should you require any assistance in intellectual property litigation matters, including appeals, please do not hesitate to contact a member of the Goodmans IP Litigation Team.
Photo Credit: https://unsplash.com/@macu_ic
Expertise
Insights
-
Intellectual Property Litigation
Hershey’s Kisses Go to Court – Federal Court of Appeal Decision in PIM Brands Inc. v. Hershey Chocolate & Confectionery LLC
The Federal Court of Appeal’s recent decision in Promotion in Motion, Inc. (PIM Brands, Inc.) v. Hershey Chocolate & Confectionery LLC offers fresh guidance on how courts evaluate survey evidence… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
CIPO Explores Fast-Tracking Patents for Innovation in Priority Sectors
Industry Minister Mélanie Joly is reportedly evaluating a proposal from the Canadian Intellectual Property Office (“CIPO”) that would accelerate patent applications in artificial intelligence… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
Rock History and Copyright: The Show Goes On
Veteran rock photographer, Neil Zlozower, reportedly sued the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame for allegedly using his copyrighted images of Eddie Van Halen in its museum exhibits without his permission… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
Patent Reinstatement Throws “Glory” Cherries in the Pits
The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Washington (“District Court”) reportedly reinstated the Canadian government’s patent for the “Staccato” cherry, developed by Agriculture and… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
Sportswear Brand Sues University Over Similarities in Merchandise
As reported by the Associated Press, Columbia Sportswear has sued Columbia University, claiming that the university infringed the sportswear company’s trademark and breached an agreement between the… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
Call Dropped: Verizon Cuts Deal in $175M Patent Clash
Verizon and Headwater Research LLC have reportedly agreed to settle a patent infringement lawsuit that ended with a $175 million USD jury verdict against the telecom giant. Headwater, a…