Canadian Securities Regulators Shine Spotlight on Soliciting Dealer Arrangements
On April 12, 2018, the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) published CSA Staff Notice 61-303 and Request for Comment – Soliciting Dealer Arrangements. The Staff Notice seeks broad feedback about if and when soliciting dealer arrangements should be permitted, following certain high profile situations in which these arrangements were used somewhat controversially. While no specific rule changes are being proposed at this time, it seems clear regulators are focused on how companies are using soliciting dealer arrangements and their impact on investors and our capital markets.
Soliciting Dealer Fees
Soliciting dealer arrangements are agreements entered into between issuers and one or more registered investment dealers (i.e., brokers) whereby the issuer pays the participating brokers a relatively small fee (usually subject to a minimum and maximum) for soliciting their clients to vote in favour of a transaction or other matter, or tender their shares to a take-over bid. One of the rationales companies often provide for adopting soliciting dealer arrangements is their inability to communicate with certain beneficial shareholders (referred to as “objecting beneficial owners”) who can only be contacted by their broker and whose instructions are required to vote or tender their shares. While not specifically regulated by corporate or securities laws, soliciting dealer fees can raise a number of legal issues depending on the circumstances, including the duty of brokers to manage conflicts of interest, securities laws governing proxy solicitation, the fiduciary duties of boards and public interest issues.
Historically, soliciting dealer arrangements have primarily been used – relatively uncontroversially – in take-over bids and some M&A voting transactions (such as plans of arrangement). More recently, however, these arrangements have been used in proxy contests to solicit votes in favour of the incumbent board, including by the boards of EnerCare (in defending against the campaign by Octavian Advisors in 2012), Agrium (in response to the proxy contest initiated by JANA Partners in 2013) and more recently by Liquor Stores N.A. (in response to the campaign by PointNorth Capital in 2017). In each case, the target board paid brokers a fee only for votes in favour of the incumbent board’s re-election, and only if the incumbent board was ultimately re-elected. The “one-sided” nature of these arrangements drew criticism from a number of sources, though the Alberta Securities Commission – in the first case in which soliciting dealer arrangements were challenged before a Canadian securities regulator – declined to intervene in the soliciting dealer arrangement adopted by Liquor Stores (see our August 14, 2017 Update, Alberta Securities Commission Weighs In On Use of Soliciting Dealer Arrangement in Proxy Contest).
In response, the CSA is now seeking input from market participants about the use of soliciting dealer arrangements in practice, as well as perspectives about the appropriateness of their terms and use in various situations. The CSA intends to evaluate feedback it receives and determine whether any further guidance or rules are necessary. The comment period is open until June 11, 2018.
It is premature to speculate about whether the CSA will impose any specific restrictions on the use of soliciting dealer arrangements. In the interim, the use of soliciting dealer fees – particularly in proxy contests – is likely to continue to be closely scrutinized.
Expertise
Authors
Insights
-
Capital Markets
CSA Finalizes Amendments to Align Non-GAAP Financial Measures Disclosure Framework with IFRS 18
On October 15, 2026, the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) published final amendments to National Instrument 52-112 – Non-GAAP and Other Financial Measures Disclosure (“NI 52-112”) and… -
Banking and Finance
Deleveraging During a Proxy Contest: Lessons from the BC Securities Commission’s Decision in Zefiro
The British Columbia Securities Commission (BCSC) recently released its reasons in Re Zefiro Methane Corp., in which it declined to rescind a share issuance that Zefiro Methane Corp. (“Zefiro… -
REITs
The Legal Industry Reviews Edition 11 - REITs Chapter
Bill Gorman, Brenda Gosselin, and Stephen Pincus have co-authored The Canadian REIT Structure in the 11th edition of The Legal Industry Reviews Canada.In this chapter, they examine the evolution of… -
Capital Markets
CSA Proposes Broad Amendments to the Issuer Bid, Take-Over Bid and Beneficial Ownership Reporting Regimes
The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) published a notice and request for comment on a broad package of proposed amendments to Canada’s issuer bid, take-over bid and early warning reporting… -
REITs
The Legal Industry Reviews Edition 10 - REITs Chapter
Bill Gorman, Brenda Gosselin, and Stephen Pincus have co-authored The Canadian REIT Structure in the 10th edition of The Legal Industry Reviews Canada.In this chapter, they examine the evolution of… -
Capital Markets
Canadian Securities Administrators Adopt Semi-Annual Reporting Pilot Project
On March 19, 2026, the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) announced the adoption of a pilot project (the “SAR Pilot”) that permits eligible venture issuers to voluntarily report on a…
Featured Work
-
Capital Markets
CIBC Capital leads C$400 million Oxford Properties Group Trust debt offering
Goodmans LLP acted for CIBC Capital Markets, as Lead Left Joint Bookrunner, and the agents in connection with a C$400 million senior unsecured notes offering for Oxford Properties Group Trust (“OPGT… -
Banking and Finance
Vital Infrastructure Property Trust completes C$300 million senior unsecured debentures offering
Goodmans LLP acted for Vital Infrastructure Property Trust in connection with its private placement offering of C$300 million aggregate principal amount of 4.865% Series C senior unsecured debentures… -
Capital Markets
Apotex Health Corp. closes $1.25 billion inaugural senior unsecured notes offering
Goodmans LLP acted for Apotex Health Corp. in connection with its private placement offering of $1.25 billion aggregate principal amount of senior unsecured notes… -
Entertainment
WildBrain announces a C$20 million substantial issuer bid
Goodmans LLP is acting for WildBrain Ltd. in connection with its substantial issuer bid to purchase, for cancellation, a number of common shares of the company for an aggregate purchase price not… -
Capital Markets
Apotex Health Corp. completes upsized $850 million bought deal secondary offering
Goodmans LLP acted for Apotex Health Corp. in connection with the closing of the upsized bought deal secondary offering of its common shares by an affiliate of SK Capital Partners, API Investment LP… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Onex Partners and co-investors acquire AirSprint
Goodmans LLP acted as M&A legal counsel to Onex Partners in connection with the acquisition of AirSprint Inc. by Onex and its co-investors…
News & Events
-
Capital Markets
Emily Hamovitch Named 2026 Lexpert Rising Star: Leading Lawyers 40 and Under
Goodmans is proud to congratulate Emily Hamovitch who has been honoured as a Lexpert® Rising Star: Leading Lawyers 40 and Under for 2026.Emily is a partner in a business law group at Goodmans. Her… -
Banking and Finance
Goodmans Recognized in the Best Law Firms - Canada 2027
Goodmans is pleased to be featured in the Best Law Firms - Canada 2027, recognizing us as one of Canada’s most exceptional law firms across 41 industries and practices.We are also honoured to be… -
Aging and Healthcare
Goodmans Honoured with Top-Tier Recognition from Chambers
We are proud to announce Goodmans has received top-tier recognition from Chambers in the Chambers Canada 2027 Guide. Recognition from Chambers is based on independent research and direct client…