Ontario Court Addresses Expense Reimbursement for Dissident Shareholders
A decision of the Ontario Superior Court in Goodwood Inc. v. Cathay Forest Products Corp. may have important implications for dissident shareholders, specifically concerning the extent to which such shareholders can have their expenses reimbursed by the corporations that are the focus of the dissident activity.
The court had earlier ordered the holding of a meeting of the shareholders of Cathay Forest, when the company’s board of directors had breached its duty to call an annual meeting and then failed to take steps to convene a meeting requisitioned by shareholders. The meeting was held, and a new board of directors was elected. The principal requisitioning shareholder then went back to court seeking an order requiring Cathay Forest to reimburse it for certain expenses.
The court based its analysis on the provisions of the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA), the corporate statute governing Cathay Forest. The CBCA does not state whether a requisitioning shareholder is entitled to reimbursement of its expenses in the case of a court-ordered meeting. The court concluded that, in such circumstances, the requisitioning shareholder should be reimbursed for those expenses that it would have been entitled to recover under the CBCA had the shareholder called the meeting. (A shareholder can requisition a meeting where the board does not call a meeting within 21 days of receiving a valid requisition. In this case the court found that it was impracticable for the shareholder to do so, given the inaction of the Cathay Forest board). Under the CBCA, a corporation is required to reimburse requisitioning shareholders (where the shareholders call the meeting, not under court order) for those expenses “reasonably incurred by them in requisitioning, calling and holding the meeting.”
The court reviewed the expenses incurred, which consisted of printing costs, the costs of the court-appointed independent chair of the meeting and the fees of the shareholder’s proxy advisory firm and legal counsel. The analysis focused on the fees of the proxy advisory firm, which had provided a broad range of services. The court ordered reimbursement for the expenses it considered to relate to the “requisitioning, calling and holding” of the meeting, such as expenses relating to the (i) making of the requisition, (ii) engagement of service providers to facilitate the meeting, (iii) retention of the independent chair, and (iv) mechanics of calling the meeting. The court did not order reimbursement for expenses relating to other matters, including: (i) strategic advice to the requisitioning shareholder before the requisition was made, (ii) strategic advice to the proposed slate of directors about the future conduct of the business of the corporation, and (iii) the production of evidence for the shareholder in support of the court order calling the meeting.
The core conclusion of the court is that the CBCA does not mandate recovery by a dissident shareholder of all costs incurred to bring about the desired corporate result, and instead speaks of reimbursement for a much narrower range of expenses. What is not clear from the Cathay Forest decision is the scope, and how it will be interpreted. The decision clearly suggests limits on the extent to which a court will order reimbursement. However, if no application is made to the court, can a board comfortably determine that a broader range of expenses should be reimbursed? If it does so, might it be subject to challenge? Given the complexity of contemporary proxy contests, the expenses of a dissident process can be significant. Going forward, the Cathay Forest case may affect how parties involved in a dissident process think about expense reimbursement.
Expertise
Authors
Insights
-
Capital Markets
CSA Finalizes Amendments to Align Non-GAAP Financial Measures Disclosure Framework with IFRS 18
On October 15, 2026, the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) published final amendments to National Instrument 52-112 – Non-GAAP and Other Financial Measures Disclosure (“NI 52-112”) and… -
Banking and Finance
Deleveraging During a Proxy Contest: Lessons from the BC Securities Commission’s Decision in Zefiro
The British Columbia Securities Commission (BCSC) recently released its reasons in Re Zefiro Methane Corp., in which it declined to rescind a share issuance that Zefiro Methane Corp. (“Zefiro… -
REITs
The Legal Industry Reviews Edition 11 - REITs Chapter
Bill Gorman, Brenda Gosselin, and Stephen Pincus have co-authored The Canadian REIT Structure in the 11th edition of The Legal Industry Reviews Canada.In this chapter, they examine the evolution of… -
Capital Markets
CSA Proposes Broad Amendments to the Issuer Bid, Take-Over Bid and Beneficial Ownership Reporting Regimes
The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) published a notice and request for comment on a broad package of proposed amendments to Canada’s issuer bid, take-over bid and early warning reporting… -
REITs
The Legal Industry Reviews Edition 10 - REITs Chapter
Bill Gorman, Brenda Gosselin, and Stephen Pincus have co-authored The Canadian REIT Structure in the 10th edition of The Legal Industry Reviews Canada.In this chapter, they examine the evolution of… -
Capital Markets
Canadian Securities Administrators Adopt Semi-Annual Reporting Pilot Project
On March 19, 2026, the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) announced the adoption of a pilot project (the “SAR Pilot”) that permits eligible venture issuers to voluntarily report on a…
Featured Work
-
Capital Markets
CIBC Capital leads C$400 million Oxford Properties Group Trust debt offering
Goodmans LLP acted for CIBC Capital Markets, as Lead Left Joint Bookrunner, and the agents in connection with a C$400 million senior unsecured notes offering for Oxford Properties Group Trust (“OPGT… -
Banking and Finance
Vital Infrastructure Property Trust completes C$300 million senior unsecured debentures offering
Goodmans LLP acted for Vital Infrastructure Property Trust in connection with its private placement offering of C$300 million aggregate principal amount of 4.865% Series C senior unsecured debentures… -
Capital Markets
Apotex Health Corp. closes $1.25 billion inaugural senior unsecured notes offering
Goodmans LLP acted for Apotex Health Corp. in connection with its private placement offering of $1.25 billion aggregate principal amount of senior unsecured notes… -
Entertainment
WildBrain announces a C$20 million substantial issuer bid
Goodmans LLP is acting for WildBrain Ltd. in connection with its substantial issuer bid to purchase, for cancellation, a number of common shares of the company for an aggregate purchase price not… -
Capital Markets
Apotex Health Corp. completes upsized $850 million bought deal secondary offering
Goodmans LLP acted for Apotex Health Corp. in connection with the closing of the upsized bought deal secondary offering of its common shares by an affiliate of SK Capital Partners, API Investment LP… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Onex Partners and co-investors acquire AirSprint
Goodmans LLP acted as M&A legal counsel to Onex Partners in connection with the acquisition of AirSprint Inc. by Onex and its co-investors…
News & Events
-
Capital Markets
Emily Hamovitch Named 2026 Lexpert Rising Star: Leading Lawyers 40 and Under
Goodmans is proud to congratulate Emily Hamovitch who has been honoured as a Lexpert® Rising Star: Leading Lawyers 40 and Under for 2026.Emily is a partner in a business law group at Goodmans. Her… -
Banking and Finance
Goodmans Recognized in the Best Law Firms - Canada 2027
Goodmans is pleased to be featured in the Best Law Firms - Canada 2027, recognizing us as one of Canada’s most exceptional law firms across 41 industries and practices.We are also honoured to be… -
Aging and Healthcare
Goodmans Honoured with Top-Tier Recognition from Chambers
We are proud to announce Goodmans has received top-tier recognition from Chambers in the Chambers Canada 2027 Guide. Recognition from Chambers is based on independent research and direct client…