Ontario Enacts Legislation Affecting Timelines in Planning Matters During the COVID-19 Emergency
On April 14, 2020, the provincial government amended the Development Charges Act, 1997 (the “DCA”) and the Planning Act as part of omnibus legislation responding to the ongoing COVID-19 emergency.
The DCA amendment extended the application of expiring development charge by-laws.
The Planning Act amendment authorized the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing (the “Minister”) to make regulations in connection with an emergency under the Emergency Management and Civil Protection Act to govern periods of time for various matters. On April 15, 2020, the Minister used this authority and filed Ontario Regulation 149/20 (the “Regulation”), which impacts various Planning Act notices and suspends various time periods under the Planning Act.
DCA Amendment
The DCA amendment extends the application of development charge by-laws that would have otherwise expired during the COVID-19 emergency. The legislation adds a new section 9.2, which provides that development charge by-laws that expired on or after March 17, 2020 and before April 14, 2020 are deemed not to have expired. These by-laws remain in force until the date that is six months after the declared emergency ends, unless they are repealed earlier. Similarly, any other development charge by-laws that expire between April 15, 2020 and six months after the declared emergency ends, will remain in force until the end of that six month period, unless repealed earlier.
This amendment does not freeze existing development charge rates but simply extends development charge by-laws that would have expired.
Planning Act Amendment and the Regulation
The Regulation issued by the Minister under the Planning Act amendment provides that the initial and more broadly-applicable regulation made under the Emergency Management and Civil Protection Act (Ontario Regulation 73/20), regarding the suspension of limitation periods and other time periods, is deemed to have never applied to the Planning Act, and instead establishes new and more specific rules for various Planning Act matters. In a letter circulated before the Regulation was issued, the Minister indicated the Regulation is intended to provide a comprehensive set of rules for determining the timing implications of the COVID-19 emergency on planning matters, while also giving municipalities flexibility to continue processing applications during the emergency if they wish to do so.
First, notices sent by municipalities between February 26, 2020 and April 15, 2020 for various Planning Act decisions are cancelled and deemed not to have been completed. Municipalities must re-issue these notices no later than 15 days after the emergency period ends. This means that any corresponding appeal period is also cancelled and would start again once the municipality issues a new notice of decision. However, any appeal filed before the re-issued notice is given remains valid.
Similarly, notice for any decision made between March 2, 2020 and the end of the emergency period that was not issued before April 15, 2020, must be issued by the municipality no later than 15 days after the emergency period ends.
Generally, the Planning Act decisions affected by these rules are:
- decisions adopting or refusing official plans and official plan amendments;
- decisions adopting or refusing zoning by-law amendments;
- decisions approving or refusing draft plans of subdivision and plans of condominium;
- decisions authorizing or refusing variances;
- decisions giving or refusing provisional consents; and
- decisions regarding community planning permits.
Nothing precludes a municipality (or Committee of Adjustment) from re-issuing any cancelled notice or issuing any new notice of decision during the emergency period. If it does so, the normal appeal period for that notice would run during the emergency period and no re-issued notice is required after the emergency period. Put another way, the Regulation does not extend appeal periods for any notices issued or re-issued during the emergency period after April 15, 2020.
Second, the Regulation suspends certain time periods under the Planning Act during the emergency period, including:
- the 30-day period for a municipality to declare an application as complete;
- the time period after which an applicant can appeal for a municipality’s failure to make a decision;
- the 15 days for a municipal clerk to compile and forward an appeal record to the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal; and
- the deadlines for registering approved plans of subdivision, fulfilling consent conditions and completing transactions in respect of which a consent has been granted.
These suspensions have various practical impacts. As two examples:
- The Regulation does not prevent the filing of a new application with a municipality, subject to a municipality being open to accepting such an application. Similarly, the Regulation does not prevent a municipality from reviewing filed applications. However, the Regulation suspends the various timelines associated with processing applications during the emergency period.
- The Regulation does not prevent the filing of an appeal for a municipality’s failure to make a decision provided that the time period for making its decision expired before March 17, 2020. However, the Regulation suspends the time period for the municipal clerk to forward the resulting appeal record to the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal, meaning the appeal could simply sit in the clerk’s office during the emergency period.
Third, the Regulation extends any interim control by-law that would have expired during the emergency period.
Looking Forward
The Ministry is expected to post an explanatory note regarding the Regulation shortly.
Expertise
Authors
Insights
-
Municipal and Land Development
Shifting Sands – Ontario Proposes More Changes to the Land Use Planning Framework through Bill 185
On April 10, 2024, the Province of Ontario introduced the Cutting Red Tape to Build More Homes Act, 2024, which proposes a number of amendments to the Planning Act and related legislation that would… -
Dispute Resolution
Director Duties and Climate Change
Decisions earlier this year from the English courts in ClientEarth v Shell Plc et al., and the recent appeal decision from the Court of Appeal of England and Wales, shed light on climate change issues… -
Environmental
OLT Clarifies When Municipalities May Prescribe Affordable Housing Requirements in Official Plans, Ontario Bar Association
Matthew Lakatos-Hayward is a contributor to the OBA Newsletter. This article appeared in the November 2023 issue.Excerpt from "OLT Clarifies When Municipalities May Prescribe Affordable Housing… -
Environmental
Supreme Court of Canada Holds Designated Projects Scheme Under the Impact Assessment Act is Unconstitutional
On October 13, 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) released its advisory decision regarding the constitutionality of the federal government’s environmental assessment (EA) regime in Reference re… -
Dispute Resolution
Downstream GHG Emissions and Sierra Club Canada Foundation v Canada (Environment and Climate Change)
The Federal Court’s recent decision in Sierra Club Canada Foundation v. Canada (Environment and Climate Change) highlights the continuing focus in Canada on climate change litigation. The case… -
Environmental
Ontario Amends the Mining Act to Streamline Closure Planning and Mineral Recovery Requirements
On May 18, 2023, the Province of Ontario granted Royal Assent to various amendments to the Mining Act through Bill 71, the Building More Mines Act, 2023 (“Bill 71”). The government’s stated purpose of…
Featured Work
-
Real Estate
Waterfront Toronto partners with Quayside Impact Limited Partnership
Goodmans LLP advised Quayside Impact Limited Partnership (“QILP”), a partnership between Dream Unlimited and Great Gulf, in connection with Waterfront Toronto’s international search for a development… -
Real Estate
Knightstone Group of Companies’ Student Residence Development Matters
Goodmans acts for the Knightstone Group of Companies as developer and tenant in the long-term ground leasing of real property from colleges and universities and the subsequent rezoning and development… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Group led by Michael Andlauer buys Ottawa Senators
Goodmans LLP acted for an entity controlled by Michael Andlauer in its purchase of the Ottawa Senators Hockey Club from the Melnyk Estate… -
Municipal and Land Development
Madison Properties Inc. Redevelopments at Yonge and Eglinton
Goodmans LLP is acting for Madison Properties Inc. in connection with various high-profile redevelopments near the intersection of Yonge Street and Eglinton Avenue in the City of Toronto… -
Municipal and Land Development
Oxford Properties Group Redevelopment at Scarborough City Centre
Goodmans LLP is acting for Oxford Properties Group in connection with the official plan and zoning by-law amendment applications for a mixed-use redevelopment west of Scarborough City Centre… -
Municipal and Land Development
Oxford Properties Group Expansion of Square One Shopping Centre
Goodmans LLP is acting for Oxford Properties Group in connection with implementing previously obtained land use approvals for the expansion and revitalization of the Square One Shopping Centre in…
News & Events
-
Banking and Financial Services
The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2024 Continues to Recognize Goodmans
We are proud to announce Goodmans LLP has once again been recognized in the 2024 edition of The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory.91 Goodmans lawyers have been recognized as top-tier in their… -
Municipal and Land Development
Matthew Lakatos-Hayward at OBA’s 2024 Ontario Legal Conference: Municipal, Planning & Environmental Law
Join Matthew Lakatos-Hayward on February 9th at 9:00 am for the Plenary: Significant Environmental Issues in Land Use Planning, session at OBA's Ontario Legal Conference… -
Environmental
Matthew Lakatos-Hayward at the OBA's Mastering Environmental Management: Crafting Environmental Management Systems and Policies
In this foundational session, a panel of environmental law experts will unpack what you need to know about the development and implementation of Environmental Management Systems (EMS). Through this…